Former officer found guilty in Birchmore death

A federal jury in Boston found a former police detective guilty of killing a young woman and her unborn child after a multi-week trial.

Beautiful courtyard view of the historic Boston Public Library under a blue sky.
Photo by Guohua Song on Pexels
Ask AI about this:ChatGPTClaudePerplexityGoogle AI

A federal jury in Boston convicted former Stoughton police detective Matthew Farwell of killing Sandra Birchmore and her unborn child. Prosecutors presented evidence during the multi-week trial proving that Farwell murdered the 23-year-old woman inside her Canton apartment on February 1, 2021.

State authorities initially ruled the death a suicide after Birchmore was found unresponsive when she failed to show up for her job as an aide at a Sharon elementary school. Federal authorities later launched an independent review and consulted medical experts who concluded she had been strangled.

During the proceedings, prosecutors demonstrated that Farwell met Birchmore when she was a minor participating in a local police youth program. Testimony and phone records revealed he engaged in an illicit relationship with her and targeted her to prevent disclosure as she grew older.

Defense attorneys argued for an acquittal by insisting that Birchmore took her own life, pointing to a previous suicide attempt and a history of mental illness. However, cellphone data presented to the jury showed movement on Birchmore's phone stopped just three minutes before Farwell visited her home.

Jurors deliberated for approximately 15 hours before returning a unanimous guilty verdict on both counts of the superseding indictment. US District Judge Denise Casper polled each juror individually in the courtroom to confirm their decision.

"We have now reached the end of this trial," Judge Casper said after the verdict was read. Farwell, age 41, faces an automatic life sentence for the federal offenses.

Acting Stoughton Police Chief James O'Connor released a statement following the court's decision to praise the outcome. "I am grateful for this verdict. It is the outcome Sandra, her unborn child, and her family have deserved for more than five years," O'Connor said, while thanking the U.S. Attorney's Office, the FBI, and the Massachusetts State Police for their investigative work.

Questions readers ask

What led to the murder investigation being reopened?

State authorities initially ruled the death a suicide, but federal authorities later launched an independent review and consulted medical experts who concluded she had been strangled.

What evidence did the prosecution use against the defendant?

Prosecutors used cellphone data showing activity stopped three minutes before Farwell visited the apartment, alongside testimony and phone records of their illicit relationship.

Quick quiz

Question 1 of 3
What is the penalty Matthew Farwell faces for the federal offenses?
Pick an answer

More Boston News

Boston votes to end parking minimums for housing

The Boston City Council voted to eliminate off-street parking requirements for new housing developments to lower construction costs.

Boston completes 28 million cummins highway project

Mayor Michelle Wu announced the completion of the $28 million Cummins Highway reconstruction project in Mattapan to improve safety.

Red Sox introduce new slugger Jake Bauers at Fenway

The Boston Red Sox officially introduced first baseman Jake Bauers on Tuesday following a four-year, $58 million contract agreement.

Megan Doyle

Megan DoyleCity hall reporter

Megan covers Boston City Hall, the MBTA and housing for NewMedia Boston.